Consumer Mattress Reviews

Providing the best reviews so you can make informed buying decisions.

Mattress Brand Comparison

Mattress Brand Comparison

Amerisleep is an online company which mainly sells memory foam mattresses. The mattresses they sell have a medium price range. Their mattresses aren’t cheaply manufactured, but boast reasonable prices for a higher level of quality mattresses made here in the USA. These eco-friendly mattresses are made from sustainable plant-based formulas. Amerisleep memory foam mattresses have a density of 4.5lb, measured one of the highest in the industry. They have a 20 year limited warranty over the whole mattress. When the mattress is delivered, you have 90 days to test the mattress and see if it is right for you. If you do not like it during that time, you can return it for a full refund.

Guarantee – 5 stars
Quality – 5 stars
Ease Of Ordering – 5 stars
Return Policy – 4 stars
Price – 3 stars

Tempur-pedic has been the leader in memory foam mattresses for years and their name has practically become synonymous with memory foam in general. This fame has come as a result of extensive advertising and quality, however expensive, their exclusive line of products. The Tempurpedic mattresses range in price from $1300 to as high as $6300. These beds have a high density that varies from 4.1lb to 5.3lb. Each mattress has either one of two types of a warranty depending on the individual mattress: a 20 year limited warranty or a full 10 year warranty. The mattress comes with a 90 day in home trial period for returns.

Guarantee – 4 stars
Quality – 4 stars
Ease Of Ordering – 5 stars
Return Policy – 4 stars
Price – 1 stars

Sealy has become one of the foremost mattress brands and their memory foam mattresses are no exception. They have two different series of memory foam mattresses: the lower end Comfort Series and the superior Embody Series. The price of their memory foam mattresses ranges from $700 to $1300 for the comfort series and $1800 to $3000 for the Embody series. One major difference between these two styles is the density, which can demonstrate the overall quality of the mattress. The density for the comfort series is between 2.5 – 4lbs, the Embody series is 5lbs. Both of these mattress styles are covered by a 10 – 20 year warranty, depending on the individual mattress. The customer also has 30 days from the time they receive the mattress to return it.

Guarantee – 3 stars
Quality – 3 stars
Ease Of Ordering – 3 stars
Return Policy – 2 stars
Price – 3 stars

Serta is another brand known for selling innerspring mattresses in addition to other styles. Their iComfort memory foam mattresses are a mid-level style mattress. The price starts at $1100 and goes up to $2400. The density of the memory foam is between 3 – 5lbs per foot. The warranty for the mattresses lasts for 25 years of ownership with the first 15 years being non-prorated. They also provide a substantial return policy in which the customer is able to return the mattress during the first 120 days, provided they have slept on it for 30 days to let their body adjust to it.

Guarantee – 5 stars
Quality – 3 stars
Ease Of Ordering – 4 stars
Return Policy – 5 stars
Price – 3 stars

Sleep Innovations is a relatively minor mattress company compared to the others discussed above. But, there is always room in the mattress market for the cheapest products. Their mattresses are some of the least expensive in the industry ranging from $280 to $950. But, with this low cost there is often low quality. The mattresses only have 3lbs of density for the memory foam. For defects and warranty issues, the mattress includes a 20 year limited warranty. The mattresses are able to be returned. Depending on the original retailer, the customer has 30 – 90 days to return the bed. If someone looking for a new memory foam bed is on a budget, they may be tempted to try Sleep Innovations. It should be noted you are never really saving money if you are losing sleep.

Guarantee – 4 stars
Quality – 1 stars
Ease Of Ordering – 3 stars
Return Policy – 3 stars
Price – 5 stars